We know that linemates have a larger impact on results than competition on the average. This has caused many to change player deployment chart axis from QoC to QoT metrics.
However, it’s not quite that simple.
The area of contextually nuanced studies with numbers like competition and teammate metrics is still well in its infancy. We have a general idea of what’s going on but there is a lot of information in the details.
We show here that a 1 percentage point change in teammate and competition Corsi% has an equal but opposite impact on observed output, but there are some differences. The distribution in the NHL is much smaller with competition. However, unlike with competition Corsi%, teammate Corsi% impact is not the same for all players.